I'm a little disappointed. Generally Tam's blog is a bullshit-free zone. Given her interest in historical weapons, I was sure she'd have some experience with Delisle carbines.I've been on the range sans ears when a modern Delisle clone was fired, as well as something very like a Welrod. And yes, they were quiet. For guns. An unabridged Webster's being dropped on a carpeted floor is quiet, too, compared to an unsuppressed firearm, but it's not something you'd want to hear while creeping up on Dr. Evil's henchmen.
Who you gonna believe? The dB meter? Or your lyin' ears? ;)
(As the video points out there, an integrally-suppressed deuce-deuce manual repeater is very quiet. So's a spring-piston .22 air rifle. Both are a lot louder than you'd think when you cap one off in your back yard at a 'possum at 0mygawd30 in the morning. Ask me how I know.)
Well, the linkyed DeLisle did sound mighty quiet on the youtube vid. Then again, the regular old high power rifles going off sounded mighty quiet, too---a lot, a lot, quieter than they seem in real life. But hey, you're mostly bullshit free, so you got that going for you!
ReplyDeleteQuick question.
ReplyDeleteYou take your uber high-tech, integrally suppressed, spring loaded .17, walk into Stevie Wonder's house, stand next to him, and let a few fly - Would he be able to tell you how many shots you fired?
If so, it's not silent.
Now, instead, do so at a party where there's a lot of background noise. Could he hear it then? Maybe not. But just because something can be masked by ambient noise doesn't mean it's silenced.
Hell, a tuba is hard to hear when you're sitting next to a running F/A-18 Jet Engine, doesn't mean it's 'silent'
Back lace? As in Tactical Corset? :)
ReplyDeleteYou're kidding. The great mall ninja suppressor controversy is still going on?
ReplyDeleteI'd have thought it would be long since superseded by the next great burning issue, like "how much does the ACU pattern suck compared to MARPAT," or something equally relevant to everyday life.
Heh, the douchebag at the other sight even agrees that it sounds like an electric typewriter...
ReplyDeleteSome people just want the counter hits from arguing. Ask me, I recently disagreed with Billy Beck and Mike Vanderbough. Never got so many counter hits in one day before.
Lissa,
ReplyDeleteD'oh!
AM,
Nah, Ernunnos is cool. I think we just have a disagreement of terminology. :)
Don't worry Tam, I hear that you can post over there if you are listening to the psychedelic furs! Lace optional!
ReplyDeleteA suppressed 22 would be perfect for my possum popping but the horses have grown accustom to the Buckmark going off.
ReplyDeleteGerry
Even a P-22 with an Outback will keep the horses from spooking or the neighbor's dogs from barking, despite midnight mag dumps (again, ask me how I know) but neither horses nor dogs are Dr. Evil's keyed-up henchmen. ;)
ReplyDeleteSome people just want the counter hits from arguing. Ask me, I recently disagreed with Billy Beck and Mike Vanderbough. Never got so many counter hits in one day before.
ReplyDeleteSo that's the secret.
OK, Tam, I'll bite. How do you know?
ReplyDeleteGotta hate a tomato-mangling possum. A .22 slip-in insert barrel in an over-and-under 12 gauge using those little Avila snap-caps works nicely. And the gardening neighbors never complain. Where I live, anyway.
ReplyDeleteneither horses nor dogs are Dr. Evil's keyed-up henchmen.
ReplyDeleteThat's just what they want you to think!
DeLisle was supposed to be quieter than working the bolt, but the absolute sound wasn't 100% of the point. Part of the point was: The loud sound was where the bullets were hitting, and that tended to get your target's companions looking behind them instead of looking for you. Of course at night the muzzle flash was not your friend, and probably was more important than the sound.
ReplyDeleteGuess I should stay off that "other" site, but the quietest I've fired was a Winchester 52D with CCI CB Longs...way quieter than the few suppressed things I've played with, which were all LE aquired SMG and no rifles or .mil. Never, ever having played some of those computer games, I really did indeed like the Ingram. But that was in my youth.
ReplyDeleteSuch things are like kids: lots of fun at first, but they are louder than you think and they get expensive to feed.
Win 52D is opposite end of bell curve from tacti-cool, though...but great medicine for squirrels!
Robb, how do you know that about tubas and F-18s? Are you suggesting tubas need suppressors too? I mean, I could see it for the oboe and the French horn, but I digress.
ReplyDeleteJim
French Horns already have suppressors. That's why they're played with one hand in the bell.
ReplyDeletePre-Computerz, I used to work a self-powered IBM Selectric when I was in fund-raising. That thing was a racket and I could barely hear my fat boss yelling at me when I was tapping the plastic keys. We had another one that was auto-magic and would nonstop type letter after letter with just a change of name and address from a stack of The Dean's paper for his signature. We had to keep it in a big enclosed box surrounded by foam or the noise would drive you nuts. We used the same font-ball that was used when Dan Rather tried to push the fake Bush letters. Wore a couple out.
ReplyDeleteEverybody knows that horses aren't henchmen, they are the boss.
ReplyDeleteJust ask Bad Horse, the Thourobred of Sin.
I know how you know... I know, too!
ReplyDeleteRef what Robb said: about twenty years ago I read about a integrally-suppressed pistol that was quiet, but specifically designed to cause the audible sound to come out like a giant fart. Idea was that people hearing it tended to roll their eyes and try to ignore it. The article claimed that it had been used to take out a politician in a commie country in a park, and until someone found the blood they thought the guy'd had a heart attack.
ReplyDeleteAnother old magazine I wish I'd kept.